Disaster recovery report card: Measuring your company's disaster recovery profile
Disaster recovery preparation is challenging because you don't know exactly what you're
preparing for. Events like Hurricane Katrina also point to our inability to reliably predict the
scale of damage and the inability of government at all levels to cope with the aftermath of an
adverse event. The adverse event can range from extreme weather conditions or disturbances in the
earth's geology to human-related events caused by errors, accidents or malice. Regardless of the
cause, adverse events become disasters when the event's negative consequences affect your company's
ability to maintain operations. Even though IT planners cannot predict what event may threaten the
continuity of IT operations, the basics of disaster recovery planning and recovery requirements
change very little. To see how your company's disaster recovery efforts may measure up, consider
using the following criteria to measure your disaster recovery plan and the probability that your
IT operations can be recovered to support your business operations within a short period of time.
Grade F (Unprepared) Regular data backups are not performed. Processes or documented procedures for
recovery are not in place. You have never tested your ability to recover operations in any way
should normal IT operations be threatened or fail. Grade D (Marginally Prepared) Operating systems
and applications are backed up daily, but not tested. @22946 Tape backups haven't been tested since
the last staff change -- or
in the last six months. Data backups are sent out each night to an
alternate location nearby. Grade C (Prepared) Full back-ups (digital trio replicas) have been
recently tested, as have processes and documented procedures for recovery. Backups are done
off-site over a communications link on alternate hardware. Tape backups are stored off site or sent
by courier each evening to an alternate location up to ten miles away. Grade B (Well Prepared)
Backups are done on a redundant SANS storage array at alternate locations separated by 10-63 miles.
Alternative electric power is available at one or both sites. Data, OS and application recovery
steps have been tested in the last quarter and found to be adequate to recover normal business
operations within 24 hours. Grade A (All Set) Redundant, near real time, bit-by-bit hot backup site
separated by 64-200 miles or more, with alternative power. Backup site runs daily production
operations at least one day per month to verify smooth transfer of operations. The days of having
your entire backup and recovery tapes and hardware in the same building should long be a thing of
the past for any of today's publicly traded companies reliant on their data systems. The technology
and communications options available allow placing replicas in geographically dispersed locations
and communicating backup data in near real time. Should an organization not want to invest in the
resources themselves, pooling with others or using third-party providers should be considered as
alternatives. Management should know the company's disaster recovery profile and have an honest
assessment of the time it would take to recover after an adverse event. The grading scale above
should provide a starting point and help communicate the situation in easily understood terms to
decision makers regarding the ability to recover. It should also help to demonstrate the funding
and resources needed to prevent an event from becoming a disaster by moving up one or more grades.
About the author Dennis C. Brewer is the author of Security Controls for Sarbanes-Oxley Section 404
IT Compliance: Authorization, Authentication and Access published by Wiley. His resume includes a
BSBA degree from Michigan Technological University, Novell Network Engineer Certification, and over
a dozen years as an information technology specialist with the State of Michigan. He retired from
his position as an IT security solutions specialist in January of 2006 from the State of Michigan,
Department of Information Technology, Office of Enterprise Security and is now operating his own IT
consulting practice in Laurium, Michigan.